June 26, 2015

No regional dump**This blog has a lot of information.  If you are concerned about what our commissioners plan to do with the landfill, please take time to read it all.**

Since the Jasper County BOC tried to pull a fast one over on the citizens and form a Regional Solid Waste Authority behind closed doors, a lot has been learned. Some of this information has come to light during the SWC meetings; some of it has been obtained through open records or just plain research.

At the January 12, 2015 BOC meeting, Karen Degges told the BOC that she was sure we could turn waste into energy at the landfill and the EPD would extend the consent order (again) to let them try. She never mentioned the letter she wrote to EPD on September 23, 2014—click on letter to enlarge:

EPD.092314.WtoEThe BOC seemed wary of this proposal, but one commissioner said, “Whatever it takes to get EPD to extend the time.” Here is copy of the entire letter.

The BOC unanimously approved letting her put this Waste to Energy plan in motion. On the same day (1/12/15) Matthew Roper, former landfill “consultant” and certified operator, wrote a letter to the BOC about how he had found someone—Waste Eliminators of Norcross, GA—that would lease the landfill and take care of all the problems. Here is a copy of that letter.

Upon further investigation, we find that Steve Harbin/Harbin Engineering, who Karen Degges mentions in her letter to EPD, works for Lamar County’s solid waste landfill—which has received a $27.5 million GEFA loan to turn “waste to energy.”   The project will cost $44 million and Gene Trammell admitted to the SWC that the BOC had looked into partnering with Lamar County on this project. Following is a copy of the information in the 5/20/14 Lamar County BOC minutes.



We question if Steve Harbin or Harbin Engineering ever had anything to do with the Jasper County plan for waste to energy at the landfill. There are no checks written to Harbin Engineering at any time in 2014 or in 2015 and Ms. Degges responded to an open records request for a copy of Harbin’s report with the letter from Matthew Roper. It appears all the information sent to EPD was a smoke screen.

Shortly after the illegal executive session held by the county attorney, Karen Degges, and the BOC to set up a Solid Waste Authority, Mary Patrick filed a complaint with the Attorney General’s office for the violations of open meetings. After an attempt by the county attorney to justify the BOC actions by saying that “if Mary Patrick doesn’t know everything in advance she thinks it is a violation,” a second response/complaint was filed with 32 additional letters signed by citizens that joined in the complaint. The Attorney General asked for more information and details from the county attorney. Here is a copy of his (the attorney’s) entire second response.

Notice in this response that Jim Alexander states that additional land acquisition was probable, even though he and all the commissioners were adamant that the landfill would not expand in public meetings. Also in his previous letter to the Attorney General he stated that they went into executive session to discuss land acquisition. Please read the letter; if you attended the meeting at the firehouse and/or the meeting in the courthouse you will see various discrepancies in what was actually said in public and what the excuses are to the Attorney General to defend the BOC against the complaint. (We are still waiting for the final determination from the Attorney General’s office.)

Public outrage along with the complaint to the Attorney General caused the BOC to overturn their Solid Waste Authority and set up a citizens committee. That committee met, worked to find solutions, and prepared a report before 6/30/15—the date set by both the BOC and the EPD when a report/plan had to be submitted to avoid $500 per day fines.   The SWC has tried in vain to submit that report in a timely manner, but the BOC and County Manager have rebuffed them. Instead that report will be submitted to the BOC on July 6, 2015 at 6:00PM.

In the meantime, Comm. Trammell has told a member of the SWC “that report y’all are doing has nothing to do with that consent order.”   He must have forgotten (remember, according to the County Manager he has memory problems) what he wrote in the SWC mission statement—Item #3 states: “This committee will meet as often as is required to complete the mission within the prescribed times as directed by Consent Order (EPD Consent Order EPD-SW-2648). Said plan stipulates that a formal plan be presented on or before June 30, 2015.”

We have learned that Comm. Trammell was going to write EPD a letter before 6/30/15. Now we have learned that Karen Degges is going to send them an email. An email is not a formal plan as required by the EPD consent order, but the BOC has gotten away with fooling them this long, maybe it will work one more time. If it doesn’t, the members of the BOC should have to pay the fines personally.

 Please pass this information on to others on your email list.


Be informed! Get involved! Plan to attend the July 6th meeting at 6:00PM. Don’t let the BOC fool us again!

This entry was posted in County, Landfill, Open Government and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.


  1. NUFF SAID says:

    After perusing all the available information on the Jasper County landfill issue, one can only conclude that either the Jasper County Board of Commissioners are complete imbeciles or are total liars …or both.How did we get to this point of incorrigible county govenrment?

  2. Boggled mind says:

    Thanks Mary! I’ve read this from start to finish and all in-between. We the citizens of Jasper County need to recall all commissioners. Mr. Alexander and Karen Degges should be fired immediately! Gene Trammel is a disgrace and to stupid to see he is being lead around like a bull with a ring in his nose by Ms. Degges. The other commissioners are also. We need lock them out of the court house before they destroy us with more of their stupid tricks.

  3. Who is the liar? Part II says:

    Mr. Alexander tells the Attorney General that “The actual activation of the Solid Waste Authority was not on the agenda simply because no one actually knew that the matter would be needed until the discussion in executive session occurred. Really? No one knew? How come Mr. Alexander had a draft resolution ready? At the very least Mr. Alexander knew and I surmise a commissioner or two did also. I can’t imagine Mr. Alexander taking it upon himself to draft a resolution for something nobody else knows about. Mr. Alexander proclaimed at a BOC meeting that he serves at the pleasure of the Board.

    In his letter he later states in part “I had originally prepared the draft activation resolution” under whose direction was this document prepared?

    He also states in part that in executive session “discussion of available land for acquisition in order to meet expansion requirements should the BOC decide at some point to move forward on the privatization.

    I am once again confused. Ms. Degges stated during the public meeting that there is 100 to 150 acres of land, that the County currently ownes, available for expansion. Why would the BOC need to acquire more land? Would 100 to 150 acres not be enough for the foreseeable future if a landfill expansion was approved? During the public meeting a person asked specifically about acquisition of land to expand the landfill and the public was told that there was absolutely nothing to that rumor.

    “Had the Authority actually been fully created by appointment of its members, it would have been a perfectly sound method for increasing public involvement in solving this difficult problem”. We now have a Solid Waste Committee comprised of only public members that can solve this difficult problem without the creation of an Authority. As Mr. Alexander himself told the public, the Authority was needed to engage in multiyear contracts.

    I have lost all faith in this Board of Commissioners, our county manager and our county attorney.

  4. Who is the liar? Part I says:

    Who is the liar?

    We have never heard a word about Harbin Engineering in open meetings. Harbin supposedly put together a project scope to reclaim fiber and reclaim material from the closed landfill to convert to energy. The project would also include, processing material from other landfills (regional approach to waste management) – this has to be more than C&D material that the BOC kept emphasizing, as one cannot economically convert C&D material into energy.

    In the letter to EPD, Ms. Degges states that Harbin has located equipment that is a good fit for our needs along with potential funding for the project through GEFA. She points out that once she is satisfied that the solution can continue to generate revenue and meet debt service requirements, the solution would then be presented to elected officials. This implies that Ms. Degges never got authorization from the BOC for any of the above tasks.

    The letter then mentions that delay in consent order enforcement would give the County additional time to flesh out this project in great detail, evaluate potential partnerships for RAW waste and other fuel sources. What exactly is raw waste?

    When Ms. Degges was hired I raised concern with the BOC over the county manager (any county manager) having too much decision making power. I was told that the county manager could not make a move without their approval. Did the BOC know about this letter to the EPD and the claims it contains?

    If the BOC had no knowledge of the letter sent to EPD than it is clear that the county manager has way too much decision making power. On the other hand, if the commissioners did know and approve of the letter, than they have made decisions out of public light and one could argue, in secret.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s